Sweet Tooth Society
Welcome to Sweet Tooth Society
Welcome to Sweet Tooth Society — a homegrown dessert brand proudly serving handcrafted, small-batch sweets made with premium ingredients and a whole lot of heart.
We specialize in classic Southern-inspired favorites like rich banana pudding, strawberry shortcake layered to perfection, and fresh-baked cookies that melt in your mouth. Every treat is made fresh with strict attention to quality, consistency, and flavor — because we believe dessert should be an experience, not just a snack.
Whether you’re celebrating something special, surprising a loved one, or simply craving something sweet for yourself, you’re in the right place. At Sweet Tooth Society, we don’t just sell desserts — we create joy in every bite.
Join the Society — and taste what everyone’s talking about.
📍 Now serving Athens, GA and surrounding areas | Pickup & limited delivery available
Discover Our Menu
Every dessert is made fresh, in small batches, using high-quality ingredients and Southern-inspired recipes that keep our customers coming back for more. Whether you’re craving something rich, fruity, or soft and chewy — we’ve got a sweet with your name on it.
Menu Overview
Banana Pudding
Customer Favorite
Creamy, layered perfection with fresh bananas, Nilla wafers, and fluffy whipped topping.
Small (9 oz.) – $5
Large (16 oz.) – $10
Strawberry Shortcake
Customer Favorite
Moist vanilla cake, juicy strawberries, and whipped cream in every sweet, spoonable layer.
Small (9 oz.) – $5
Large (16 oz.) – $10
Cookies
Just Like Grandma’s
Soft-baked classics — buttery chocolate chunk cookies and cinnamon-swirled snickerdoodles
3 Cookies – $6
6 Cookies – $10
Place Your Custom Order
For all catering inquiries and large custom orders, please complete the form below. This helps us ensure every detail is handled with care and allows us to better accommodate your event needs, whether it’s for a celebration, gathering, or corporate occasion.
Please Note: Due to high demand and limited availability, we recommend submitting your request at least 7–10 days in advance to secure your preferred date.
To place your custom order, call us at (706) 296–6065 or use the form below.
Sweet Tooth Society
Sweet Tooth Society was born out of a deep love for desserts and a passion for bringing people joy through food.
What started as a simple banana pudding recipe quickly turned into a growing menu of Southern-inspired sweets, crafted with care and made fresh in small batches.
We’re proud to serve our local community with treats that feel like home, taste like love, and leave you wanting more. Whether you’re here for a quick craving or a custom order, we’re so glad you stopped by — and we can’t wait to serve you something sweet.
Open Hours
Sun: Closed
Mon – Tue: 12:00 pm – 5:00 pm | Delivery Only
Wed – Sat: 4:00 pm – 10:00 pm | Pickup & Delivery
Location
Athens, GA + Surrounding Areas
Contact Us
(706) 296 6065
sweettoothsocietyco@gmail.com
Sweet Tooth Society 